Paige V State of Vermont and Barack Hussein Obama update, December 7, 2013, H Brooke Paige filed motion for reargument on November 15, 2013, Natural born citizen definition, Mootness

Paige V State of Vermont and Barack Hussein Obama update, December 7, 2013, H Brooke Paige filed motion for reargument on November 15, 2013, Natural born citizen definition, Mootness

“Why has Obama, since taking the White House, used Justice Department Attorneys, at taxpayer expense,  to avoid presenting a legitimate birth certificate and college records?”…Citizen Wells

“Barack Obama, show me the college loans.”…Citizen Wells

“It is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial
department to say what the law is. Those who apply the rule to
particular cases, must of necessity expound and interpret that
rule. If two laws conflict with each other, the courts must
decide on the operation of each.”

“If then the courts are to regard the constitution; and the
constitution is superior to any ordinary act of the legislature;
the constitution, and not such ordinary act, must govern the
case to which they both apply.”
“The judicial power of the United States is extended to all
cases arising under the constitution. Could it be the intention
of those who gave this power, to say that, in using it, the
constitution should not be looked into? That a case arising
under the constitution should be decided without examining the
instrument under which it arises?  This is too extravagant to
be maintained.”

“Why does a judge swear to discharge his duties agreeably to the
constitution of the United States, if that constitution forms no
rule for his government? if it is closed upon him, and cannot be
inspected by him?”… Marbury versus Madison



I received an update from H. Brooke Paige yesterday, December 7, 2013.

Mr. Paige filed a motion on November 15, 2013 for a reargument before the Vermont Supreme Court.

“2- The Appellant’s supporting brief request this court to consider and
favorably amend its decision of October 18, 2013 to more accurately depict
the record and more succintly annunciate its decision relating to the
following issues and reverse its decision as to mootness and rule on the
underlying issues as to law:

a – Correct the record to accurately documents the Appellant’s definition
of “natural born citizen” as consistently advanced and articulated
throughout the record.

b – Correct the record to accurately document the Plaintiff/Appellant’s
efforts to advance and expedite the action to a timely conclusion.

c – Fully delineate and document the Appellee’s efforts and actions to
delay and impair the advancement of this action both in the lower court and
before this Court creating a pall of “mootness” to despoil he (sic)
appellant’s effort to obtain a decision based on the merits of his case.

d – To reverse its decision that this case is mootness.

e – To render a decision on the definitional standard that should be
applied by the Vermont Courts as to the meaning of the Constitutional
Presidential Qualification of “natural born citizen” so as to remove the
confusion that currently exist for those involved in the Vermont Election
process at currently exist for those involved in the Vermont Election

From Citizen Wells October 19, 2013.

“I received the email from H. Brooke Paige last night.

“VT Sup Court ruled today. Interesting decision that will allow us to
proceed to SCOTUS.”

Instead of expediting this case the lower court and VT Supreme Court dragged their feet thus making their decisions after the election.

In essence, the case is moot because Obama is already president and cannot run again.”

From the Vermont Supreme Court response.

“¶ 9. Recognized principles of mootness apply to the present case because it no longer involves a live controversy. Plaintiff has no legally cognizable interest in the outcome. Barack Obama’s name was on the ballot, and he is now the President of the United States. President Obama is also unable to seek re-election.”

Obama is not president if he is not a natural born citizen.

30 responses to “Paige V State of Vermont and Barack Hussein Obama update, December 7, 2013, H Brooke Paige filed motion for reargument on November 15, 2013, Natural born citizen definition, Mootness

  1. Congressmen Demand James Clapper Prosecuted For Lying to Congress
    This is huge. Remember, lying to congress is a felony, and yet James Clapper, Eric Holder, and Hillary Clinton have been getting away with it… until now.

  2. “Doctors boycotting California’s Obamacare exchange”

    “An estimated seven out of every 10 physicians in deep-blue California are rebelling against the state’s Obamacare health insurance exchange and won’t participate, the head of the state’s largest medical association said.”

  3. Why is it news that a Sheriff in SC won’t lower the flag to half mast for Mandela? It may be petty, but it is his option. Shouldn’t it be news that the President lied once again that he didn’t know his illegal alien uncle when in fact he lived with him? If Bush lied about knowing his uncle all the liberals would be howling. When CNN wonders why their ratings are so low and why the country is divided, it is because they keep pushing this polarizing propaganda on TV.

  4. Liberal Legal Expert: Obama Has Become Danger to Constitution

    Jonathan Turley, a noted liberal Georgetown University law professor who represented members of Congress in a lawsuit over the Libyan war, represented workers at the secret Area 51 military base, and served as counsel on national security cases, says Barack Obama is a danger to the U.S. Constitution.


  5. GOP Members Tell Investigators They’re Afraid to Expose Obama’s ID Fraud

  6. Tina | December 8, 2013 at 6:32 pm
    Tina, I think people naturally seek the truth. They don’t like BS, so they migrate to the sites they believe are telling the truth, and that’s not CNN, NBC, CBS, MSNBC, or ABC, and for liberals, that makes FOX the enemy.

  7. Losing his Voting Base: Poll Shows Obama’s Approval Plummeting with Key Groups for Democrats

    President Obama owes his election to the highest office to, in large part, the voting power of the Democrat base. With a strong emphasis on courting minority, female, young and impoverished voters, Democrats have long relied upon these groups for election and the candidacy of Senator Obama was no exception.

    However, it seems that the spell of “hope and change” has worn off as President Obama’s popularity has plummeted with groups upon which he had previously relied for support.

    According to a shocking Gallup Poll released on Thursday, President Obama is losing ground with his base, including Hispanics whose favorable opinion of the president has plummeted a whopping 23 points since December 2012.
    The poll juxtaposes December 2012, right after the president’s reelection, with November of 2013, which found President Obama mired in scandal after scandal and the Obamacare disaster.

    – Hispanics responded with a 75% job approval rating for Obama in 2012; now it’s 52%- down 23 points.

    -Those responding with an annual income of under $24,000 offered a 64% approval rating in 2012; now it’s 46%- down 18 points.

    – Nonwhites maintained an 82% approval rating for the president in 2012; now it’s 65%- down 17 points.

    -Moderate Democrats were at 89% job approval in 2012; now it’s 73%- down 16 points.

    -18-29 year olds, a key demographic for the 2008 candidate, offered a 61% approval rating in 2012; now it’s 46%- down 15 points.

    – Women favored President Obama in 2012 with a 57% approval rating; now it’s 43%- down 14 points.

    The list divides voters into many different categories and tracks the President’s fall from grace as the strongest supporting groups for Obama have become, seemingly, disenfranchised with the candidate who once promised hope, change, prosperity and transparency.

    The take-away lesson from the Gallup Poll, however, is that President Obama has become a liability for the Democrats. While many Democrat lawmakers attempt to remain by the side of their president, it is getting harder and harder for Democrats to pretend that there is not something seriously wrong with the leadership of this administration.

    Further, it is becoming more and more obvious to those who dared to hope for change that an evident bait-and-switch has occurred as Obama has mirrored the some of the more controversial policies of his predecessors while bungling many important issue facing Americans.

    What the Gallup Poll represents is a dramatic fall from grace for the 44th president who has been long on excuses but short on results. It may soon be time for Democrats to cut bait and distance themselves from the disastrous Obama presidency if they hope for reelection.

  8. Yes, Bob, I agree. Thanks for all the good info you post here. People are listening. We will one day overcome. We have to. Freedom and the truth always wins eventually.

  9. Old Scam: Global Warming… New Scam: Climate Change will Cause Killer Winter Storms for Next 30 Years

  10. Tina, it would be a shame if the truth were never known about this usurper, and history did nothing to right the wrongs of his administration.

    We are not living in fantasy land.

  11. Philo-Publius

    “We are living the movie Idiocracy…we are right in the middle of it.”

  12. Plamegate cover-up: Judith Miller is reaching out to Scooter Libby for help

  13. From CDR Kerchner:

    “Washington Times Full Page Ad: Obama’s Selective Service Draft Registration Form Back Dated and Forged! — Washington Times National Weekly — Monday – 09 Dec 2013 issue – pg 5”

  14. CDR Kerchner’s comment at CFP:

    “In addition to the crude “higher-tech” forged Obama birth certificates (short-form of Jun 2008 and long-form of Apr 2011) let us also remember the crude “lower-tech” forgery of Obama’s Selective Service Draft Registration form. This forgery was done on his behalf by someone close to Obama and his operatives and who had connections inside the Chicago regional office of the Selective Service System. This not a theory but a real conspiracy with many agents working to infiltrate the nation’s highest offices by putting into the Oval Office the total fraud Obama who can then appoint other communist operatives to high positions — to destroy our economic power, military power, and our constitutional republic:”

  15. Aka Barry Soetoro in NOT a Natural Born Citizen since evidence shows he was\still is an Indonesian national.

  16. December 8, 2013

    “TPPH Drops Obama Fraud Bomb; Smoking Guns Found; Prosecution”

    “Text via the video:

    The wait is almost over…

    People will be prosecuted…

    The smoking guns have been found…

    Witnesses will testify…

    Shocking new evidence confirms…

    Document fraud has been committed…

    We know who!

    We know how!

    We know why!

    And we know when!”

  17. “Mark Gillar is the host of Tea Party Power Hour and is the voice-over in the Cold Case Posse’s Obama fraud video presentations…”




  18. I think Reggie should be tried for TREASON too! You know he knows!

  19. Interested Bystander

    GORDO | December 9, 2013 at 12:01 pm |,

    We’ve seen this movie before. Wasn’t it him and Zullo who was telling us this Summer that “something” big was going to happen “soon”?

    Nothing against you Gordo, you bring some great stuff to the blog (even this), but how many times do we have to hear this?

    I hope I’m wrong, but ……………………..

    If they know “who”, then they should release the information.

    If they know “when”, then they should give us proof.

    If they know “why”, then they should tell us.

    There’s no reason why they couldn’t release the information. Hoping for prosecution is futile while Holder is AG. Besides, Obama could simply pardon the person, and that would pretty much be the end of the story.

    I don’t mean to be so negative, but we have known the truth for almost 6 years now.

    Obama was born to an American AND British citizen.

    He is NOT a natural born citizen.

    But yet not ONE person in the media will even tell the truth.

  20. A long, long, list of Obama’s crimes and scandals

  21. Bombshell: 120,000+ Obamacare Enrollments Aren’t “Real”

    Obamacare is essentially nothing more than outright fraud. Now, ABC has reported that over 120,000 enrollments aren’t even “real”. Please SHARE.

  22. From CDR Kerchner:

    Document Expert Doug Vogt Will be Tonight’s Guest with Host Mike Volin of Wheres Obamas Birth Certificate Radio Show | CDR Kerchner (Ret)’s Blog

  23. December 9, 2013

    “North Carolina Knock Out Attacks Lead To Three Arrests – Three Non-Mythical Arrests”

    “NORTH CAROLINA – WINTON – Another unprovoked assault – apparently part of a national craze known as the “Knockout game” – has netted several arrests as well as prompting Hertford County Sheriff Juan Vaughan to issue a stern warning.

    “This type of activity will not be tolerated here in Hertford County. Those participating in Knockout will be arrested and I feel certain that our District Attorney will prosecute those involved to the fullest extent of the law,” Vaughan stated.

    The latest arrests involve three individuals, including one previously charged by the Ahoskie Police Department for a similar crime.

    Vaughan reported that 19-year-old Kentrell Devonte Freeman of 143 Mooretown Road, Powellsville; Eric Stephenson, 22, of 1842 HWY 561 East, Cofield; and 22-year-old William McCoy White Jr. of 516 North McGlohon Street, Ahoskie were all arrested for simple assault.”
    “A Myth? Video Emerges Of Wisconsin “Knock Out Attack” – Victim 53-year-old Tim Bessette”

    “He [Bessette] remembers getting off the bus, walking down the street and encountering four youths. The next thing Bessette knew, he was sucker-punched in the nose. The world went black, and Bessette woke up on the pavement. And as he did, he heard the youths running away, joking and laughing.

    Here’s The Update – The Wisconsin Free has obtained exclusive video from a security camera of yet another victim of the so-called “Knockout Game,” also known as “Point ‘em Out, Knock ‘em Out.” The latest incident occurred near the Milwaukee Collegiate Academy at 4030 North 29th St. in Milwaukee.”

    Published on December 8, 2013

  24. December 9, 2013

    Matt Vespa:

    “Knockout Game Goes Terribly RIGHT as Woman Wails on Her Attacker”

    “Well, this participant of the knockout game probably will reconsider future engagements after being beatdown by the woman he punched.

    The video shows the assailant targeting the woman, who doesn’t go down after he lands his punch. She turns around and starts punching him repeatedly in the head – but, only after the man next to her delivers an epic kick to the face.

    According to, the incident occurred in a Las Vegas, Nevada shopping mall.”

    [video at link]

  25. December 9, 2013
    Thomas Lifson:

    “Hilarious: MSNBC host likens word ‘ObamaCare’ to n-word”

    “MSNBC is the gift that keeps on giving, serving up propaganda intended to benefit the far left, but which in its absurdity repels people grounded in reality. Now, one of its hosts, Melissa Harris-Perry, already familiar to AT readers for her theater of the absurd political performance art, has played a race card so bizarre that it self-discredits.”

    “MSNBC Doesn’t Want You Calling It ObamaCare any Longer – Or Else They’ll Call You Racist, Or Something…”

    “(Via Daily Caller) MSNBC host Melissa Harris-Perry suggested the term “Obamacare” and the N-word are interchangeable, claiming both were “conceived by a group of wealthy white men who needed to . . . render [a black man] inferior and unequal and diminish his accomplishments.”

  26. December 9, 2013

    Jeffrey Meyer:

    “MSNBC’s Harris-Perry Uses ‘Derogatory’ Term ObamaCare Two Weeks Before Condemning It”

    “MSNBC weekend host Melissa Harris-Perry has a tendency to wax sanctimonious when the camera light goes on and she takes to the air.

    So it’s our pleasure to note her utter hypocrisy when it comes to how to describe the president’s signature legislative accomplishment, the ObamaCare health care overhaul.”

    [video at link - go to 1:20]
    Comment by So you say:

    “Nice try, you racist.

    What Harris-Perry is not so subtly trying to do is equate the word Obamacare with the N-word in a futile attempt to get people to stop using the word and stop associating Obama with the failure called Obamacare.

    She wants people to react to the use of the word Obamacare like they do to the N-word. Sorry Harris-Perry, I know how much you libs like re-defining words, but Obamacare will always be associated with Obama no matter how you try to spin it.”

  27. Pingback: Paige v. State of Vermont et al, US Supreme Court Writ of Certiorari, March 7, 2014, Update, Mario Apuzzo and counsel, Obama eligibility, Natural born citizen deficiency | Citizen WElls

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s