Obama Indonesian citizen, Obama lies, Obama motion to dismiss, Philip J Berg lawsuit, Amended complaint, John Lavelle motion, Judge Surrick ruling

Barack Obama is still hiding his Indonesian citizenship behind legal
maneuvering and legalese. Today, Monday October 20, 2008, Obama filed another motion. The motion today was to dismiss Philip J Berg’s
amended complaint. Jeff Schreiber reports the following:

“Monday, October 20, 2008
Obama, DNC File Motion to Dismiss Berg’s First Amended Complaint
Just a few minutes ago, attorneys for Illinois Sen. Barack Obama and the Democratic National Committee filed a motion to dismiss the first amended complaint, a motion for leave for which was filed by Philip Berg on Monday, October 6.

Generally, an amended complaint cannot simply be filed by an attorney — the attorney must file a motion with the court, called a motion for leave to file an amended complaint, essentially asking that the court permit the amended complaint to be filed. That motion, the October 6 motion, is one of more than ten pending pleadings and still has not been addressed by the Hon. R. Barclay Surrick.

I am just now taking a look at it, but from a quick glance it appears as though Obama and the DNC are moving to dismiss the amended complaint on the same grounds for which they moved to dismiss the original complaint — that Berg lacks standing and fails to assert a claim upon which relief can be granted.


On September 24, 2008, Defendants Democratic National Committee (“DNC”) and Senator Barack Obama filed a motion to dismiss the original Complaint filed in this case, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(1) and 12(b)(6), on the grounds that the Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction over the claims asserted and that the Complaint fails to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. On October 6, 2008, plaintiff Philip Berg filed a Motion for Leave to File a First Amended Complaint, together with a First Amended Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief (“Amended Complaint”). Assuming that no leave to amend is required under Fed. R. Civ. P. 15(a) because defendants have not filed a responsive pleading,1 the First Amended Complaint should nevertheless be dismissed, on the same grounds. No amendment to the Complaint can possibly cure its fundamental defects. Not only are the allegations patently false, but plaintiff lacks standing and there is no federal cause of action for enforcement of Article II of the Constitution. Nor has plaintiff set forth, i n the Amended Complaint, any other viable federal cause of action.”

Read more here:


Support Philip J Berg in upholding the Constitution:


19 responses to “Obama Indonesian citizen, Obama lies, Obama motion to dismiss, Philip J Berg lawsuit, Amended complaint, John Lavelle motion, Judge Surrick ruling

  1. when will we hear the MO tapes?

  2. I like your optimism WATCHING, but do they exist? I’m still waiting for the “October Surprise.” With only two weeks left in the campaign, where are all the smoking guns?

  3. Ok this is interesting Sean Hannity just reported that Nobamama is taking leave to go back to Hawii to see his grandmother who is ill. Could this be a tactic to hide his birth cert……….as a new law suit has been filed there? He will be leaving on Wednesday and return to campgain on Satruday

  4. Yeah, just saw that BO is leaving his campaign for a couple of days to return to Hawaii b/c his “mother has become seriously ill.” Convenient timing. It’s possible I suppose, but definitely makes you scratch your head. Is the birth certificate going to be manufactured now and mysteriously appear??

  5. HillBuzz also reported that she is very ill and has been “had been released from the hospital .”

    They asked ” to put politics aside for a minute and say a pray for Obama’s grandmother. ”

    Seems like a ‘crisis’.


  6. And now The Messiah is descending on the island to see his “sick” granny – what a lame cover…to snuff out Andy Martin and his lawsuits filed in Hawaii to get to the bottom of the NON birth certificate……Dog Chapman to the Rescue!!! Go Dog, Go!

  7. Check this out. GO ANDY!! hahahaha

    This on gretawire, says BO grandmother is ailing.

    I hope his grandmother is okay, but I really think he’s going to Hawaii to deal with the court writ.

    ***GO ANDY***

  8. Listening,

    If BO’s grandmother is really ill, why is BO taking his time to go be with her, and how could he know that she’d be well enough for him to leave on Saturday? The guy has $150 million and a private jet for God’s sake! If his grandmother was really sick he’d leave NOW.

    I think BO’s a liar. He’s lied about most everything else, why should we believe anything he says now? IMO, it is about the birth certificate lawsuit.

    And, furthermore, he needs to bring that poor old woman home. She’s been cooped up like a dog in that old apartment long enough!!


    Philip Berg, in our conversation this evening, was similarly dissapointed by the apparent backtracking by the folks at African Press International.

    “Everything depends upon what they actually have,” Berg said, mentioning what was reported earlier as an apparent attorney-client relationship in the works between him and API. “I need to speak with them again.

    I asked him why he would agree to talk about representation without seeing, firsthand, the evidence in question. Berg said that the representation talks were essentially in preliminary stages, and nothing was set in stone.

    “They supposedly have documentation confirming the telephone records,” he said. “I will only represent them if they provide me with the documentation that they said they have, including the telephone records and the audiotape. Otherwise, if they provide me with nothing of what they promised, I will not be associated with them.”


  10. Something is up with this? He keeps his grandmother gagged and in the shadows and now he is all of a sudden concerned about her. I think he knows Andy Martin is on to him and he is going back to trouble shoot! Somebody better get to Grandma FIRST!

  11. Berg: “Obama & DNC Admit all Allegations”

    According to Rule 36 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, a party upon whom requests for admissions have been served must respond, within 30 days, or else the matters in the requests will be automatically deemed conclusively admitted for purposes of the pending action.


  12. Jeff Schreiber has reported on another legal development regarding Berg vs Obama.

    In a nutshell:

    “According to Rule 36 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, a party upon whom requests for admissions have been served must respond, within 30 days, or else the matters in the requests will be automatically deemed conclusively admitted for purposes of the pending action.

    On September 15, Philip Berg served Barack Obama and the Democratic National Committee with a request for admissions. The Federal Rules require that a response be filed within the 30-day time limit, and Barack Obama and the DNC have not.”

    Details here:


  13. Biden & McCain have released their medical records (not sure about Palin). Obama WILL NOT.

    His medical records have all kinds of information in them (diseases, treatments, addictions, medications)… possibly including, his nation of birth.

    Another issue the msm is NOT asking about.

  14. Another DNC maneuver to keep the information from the voters. JUST RELEASE THE INFORMATION AND PUT THE ISSUE TO REST.
    They call themselves the Democratic National Committee, but in a democratic society, people are supposed to make an informed vote. Fighting to keep information hidden from the people, and forbidding them to make informed votes, should have died when glasnost (openness) began. Is the DNC building a new Soviet Union here?
    Where there is secrecy, there is no truth;
    Where there is no truth , there is no justice ; Where there is no justice, there is no freedom.

  15. My book will soon be finished and other factors relating to Obama such as the real reason he was against the Iraq War. Khalif, and Rezko both had friends in Iraq at the time making money from the sell of arms and munitions to Saddem Hussein. They backed Obama’s Campaigns for the past 25 years and they did not want to loose thier investment. During those years he was being groomed by the muslim extremeist to defeat our country from within, even Osama Bin Laden, as said this would happen and because we will be crushed from within by our own government. Humiliation, will be their goal.

  16. thommacnamara

    Those who think that George W. Bush has been a great president object to the way that the so-called Republican John McCain has treated George W. Bush, a great president, a true conservative, and a greaat man.

    In this interview with the Washington Times, a conservative newspaper, McCain treats Bush worse than Obama has. See http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2008/oct/23/mccain-lambastes-bush-years/

    In this article, McCain says this of Bush:

    “Sen. John McCain on Wednesday blasted President Bush for building a mountain of debt for future generations, failing to pay for expanding Medicare and abusing executive powers, leveling his strongest criticism to date of an administration whose unpopularity may be dragging the Republican Party to the brink of a massive electoral defeat.

    “We just let things get completely out of hand,” he said of his own party’s rule in the past eight years.

    And he said:

    “He rejected Mr. Bush’s use of issuing “signing statements” when he signs bills into law, in which the president has suggested that he would ignore elements of the bills, labeling them potentially unconstitutional.

    “I would veto the bills or say, ‘Look, I don’t like it but I’ll obey the law that’s passed by Congress and signed by the president.’ I think the signing statements was not a correct implementation of the power of the executive. I think it was overstepping,” he said.

    And Mr. McCain emphatically rejected Mr. Bush’s claims of executive privilege, often used to shield the White House from scrutiny.”

    WE who believe that all these things were good and that Bush has the right under the constitution to executive privilege object to McCain’s treatment of a good and noble president.

    If Obama had said this we conservatives would rally to Bush’s support. But now that McCain has said it we have to keep quiet. We have to pretend that the policies and leaders of the last eight years were terrible, when they have been wonderful.

    McCain has undermined everything we stand for. How can we vote for him? Of course, we should not vote for Obama. But why should we vote for McCain? He has no principles. He’s not a Republican.

    I’m voting for Bob Barr, the Libertarian Party’s candidate for president. I suppose he does not like President Bush much either, but that is because Bob Barr thinks that Bush has not been conservative enough. Sad situation not to vote for a Republican. But how can we vote for McCain after he has turned his back on his party and his good president.

  17. Sharon Reynolds

    A Birth certificate is not an exclusive private record, as all citizens are required to produce it for various agencies. The sealing of obama’s certificate, unless he chooses to reveal it is an outrage. He is running again for public office, not yet elected by the electors. The people have a right to view the records of a potential president, as they have to vote with proper and full disclosure of the facts. Is America a fascist entity already and we just never knew it?

  18. I found this on The Obama File
    I don’t want my name posted please..

    Upstream blog reports that the “We The People Foundation” will publicly challenge Obama, using Obama’s hometown newspaper, the Chicago Tribune, to direct the State of Hawaii to provide access to his original, “vault copy,” birth certificate. The Foundation’s full-page “Open Letter to Barack Obama” will appear in the Chicago Tribune next Monday and Wednesday.

    “Under our Constitution, no one is eligible to assume the Office of the President unless he or she is a “natural born citizen,” said Bob Schulz, Chairman of the Foundation. “To date, Mr. Obama has refused all requests to release his original birth certificate or other documents that would definitively establish his citizenship status and thus his eligibility.”

    The Open Letter to Mr. Obama summarizes the evidence against Mr. Obama and the adverse consequences that would befall the Nation should he assume the Office of the President as a usurper.

    “Should the state members of the Electoral College cast their votes for Mr. Obama in the face of such overwhelming evidence, and without verification of Mr. Obama’s eligibility, they would be committing treason to the Constitution,” said Schulz.

    A copy of the Open Letter can be viewed here. Check it out. It’s dynamite!

    Click to access ChicagoTribune-ObamaLtr-Nov-2008.pdf

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s