Paige v. State of Vermont et al Docket 2016-202 November 30,2016 – 10:30 am, Plaintiff H. Brooke Paige, Natural born citizen status of Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio challenged, Issue not moot since Rubio and Cruz are considering another run for president
“To his kind of judge, Cruz ironically wouldn’t be eligible, because the legal principles that prevailed in the 1780s and ’90s required that someone actually be born on US soil to be a “natural born” citizen. Even having two US parents wouldn’t suffice. And having just an American mother, as Cruz did, would have been insufficient at a time that made patrilineal descent decisive.”…Laurence H. Tribe, Harvard Law Professor
“Ted Cruz wrote the forward for U.S. Constitution for Dummies which clearly reveals that he is not a natural born citizen.”…IL ballot challenger Bill Graham
“Moore said he’s seen no convincing evidence that Obama is a “natural born citizen” and a lot of evidence that suggests he is not.”…Judge Roy Moore interview by WND
From H. Brooke Paige today, November 29, 2016.
“Oral Arguments Before the Vermont Supreme Court in Paige v. State of
Vermont, et al* – Docket 2016-202 scheduled for November 30,2016 – 10:30
am
Justice moves slowly here in the Green Mountains, even when you are on an
expedited schedule. My ballot challenge which began last fall with a
complaint to the Secretary of State’s elections office was appealed to the
Vermont Superior Court last December. By February all necessary parties
had been enjoined and the process of briefs, reply briefs and sur-reply
brief were submitted in a timely fashion. The Superior Court ruled as
expected finding that, contrary to establishes precedents in the state,
that I had no standing, the court had no jurisdiction and the issues were
either moot or not yet ripe ! Judge Tomasi did not address the
“natural-born Citizen” issue directly, however did refer to and speak
approvingly of “the recent and exhaustive treatment of the natural-born
citizen issue by New Jersey Administrative Judge Jeff Masin in Williams v.
Cruz No. STE 5016-16,(April 12, 2016 Office of Admin. Law N.J.).” and thus
provided the opportunity to address the issue on appeal
The appeal process of principle brief, opposition briefs and finally my
reply brief were all completed by appellee’s State of Vermont and Mr.
Cruz. Mr. Rubio decided not to participate in the appeal process relying
on the Vermont State Attorney General to represent his interests. Nothing
in the Appellee’s briefs provided any new insight to the issue merely
reciting the well-worn writings of Jack Maskell’s Congressional Research
Service” report, the latest version including his ever expanding
definition which attempts to be inclusive of the birth circumstances of
both Rubio and Cruz! Interestingly, a recent ruling on a local ballot
challenge, Noble v. Sec’y of State, is directly on point as standing,
jurisdiction, venue and timeliness, all ruled in the plaintiff’s favor
allowing the case to proceed to the merits. Additionally, since the Court
preciously noted that since Rubio and Cruz are considering another run
for president the passage of the current election cycle does not make the
question of their “nbC” qualification moot.
So tomorrow is the day, I have spent a great deal of time reviewing the
briefs and related material and I guess I am as prepared as I can be. It
is a daunting and challenging task for a pro se litigant to face off
against the resources of the state and two sitting U.S. senators. Please
ask your followers to say a prayer for me; a little divine intervention
would be most helpful.
All the Best,
Brooke”
Perhaps this will make it to the “Trump” US Supreme Court.
This issue must be settled for the good of the country.
Natural Born Citizen.
I salute Mr. Paige for his efforts.
More here:
Citizen WElls 
“It is exciting to have defendants who, because of their divergent
political leanings refuse to cooperate in developing a unified strategy to
extinguish the humble, tenacious plaintiff. Unfortunately, the attorneys
for Rubio and Cruz seem amazingly unfamiliar with the “natural born
citizen(ship)” subject matter – regurgitating the tripe and drivel
regularly posted on “obot” websites; while Daloz, the state’s Asst. A/G,
appears to be doing a “cut and paste” job from his 2012 effort. Truly sad
to see such vacuous “work product” for these high priced “Blackstone
Lawyers.” (Thomas Jefferson complained that “many a law student finds
Blackstone’s writings – a smattering of everything, and his indolence
easily persuades him that if he understands Blackstone , he is a master of
the whole body of law.”)”
https://citizenwells.com/2016/02/19/ted-cruz-vermont-eligibility-lawsuit-update-february-19-2016-plaintiff-h-brooke-paige-cruz-not-natural-born-citizen-cruz-born-in-canada-in-1970-canadian-citizenship-act-of-1976-cruz-born-a-can/
CW……….
………….I am a strong believer in rule of law. I hope ,and pray that one day the NBC issue will be put before a 9 justice SCOTUS for clarification ONCE AGAIN, and hopefully the LIBERALS will start treating the Constitution for what it is……instead of what it isn’t. Constitutional law is what it is, and is written NOT TO BE INTERPRETED, but to be applied as such. Now that we have a conservative government soon to take over, we will soon see if the lower courts will follow suite. There are many lower court judges who need to be removed from the bench. In addition it is extremely important that Soetoro’s eligibility needs to be proven one way or the other……….because we have no way of knowing the validity of the appointments of two of the SCOTUS members. This screams for adjudication and let the chips fall where they will.
CW…….
…….Should the courts find Cruz is INELIGIBLE then the 8 year Soetoro occupation of the White House must also be closely examined to determine if he was a legitimate POTUS or not. If the Lucas Smith CERTIFIED COPY of Soetoro’s Kenya BC is accepted into discovery it will hopefully be the beginning of a hell of a bunch of people in the government who will also need to be prosecuted because of being COMPLICIT in TREASON. This must include ALL no matter their legal, political, or social status………..and among the first to be convicted must be Mzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. POSI. She KNOWINGLY signed a REWORDED, AND THEREFORE INVALID COE DOCUMENT, prepared by the DNC of Hawaii which she knowingly passed along as valid. Hopefully she will ultimately be prosecuted for her criminal act. Harriet Reed needs to be prosecuted for his part in the FRAUDULANT election. There are MANY others as well. I believe that the Lucas Smith document is VALID.
in addition the SIMPLE FACT that there WAS AN OBAMA BC on file at the Kenya Board of Health, from which the Lucas Smith copy was made, and CERTIFIED BY AN OFFICER of the institution, SPEAKS CLEARLY. Very strong evidence……..No honest judge could, or would ignore the validity of the certified copy. Lucas Smith signed an affidavit wherein he stated that he obtained the copy, and had it certified. The fact that it IS A CERTIFIED COPY it can, and should be used in discovery.
Then we have the matter of the Chief Justice who swore in an individual who he MIGHT HAVE known was NOT ELIGIBLE. Which may have been a part of the reason why the swear in was taken behind CLOSED DOORS………….which had never before happened in our 200 year history. There was more than COMPELLING REASON. If the Chief Justice knew , or even suspected something was wrong he should have refused to swear Obama in…………which seems to say that he must have been COMPLICIT in the FRAUD as well. Time will tell……….This issue is NOT GOING TO GO AWAY. I think that Larry Klayman, will continue digging. He would make a great special prosecutor to be appointed by Jeff Sessions.
CW………
…………in the first 100 days of his presidency I pray that Trump will CLEAN HOUSE at the DOJ. This is an absolute MUST DO, to get rid of the LIBERAL MISFITS. We still have no idea what Sessions is made of. As AG I believe that he WILL BE TESTED early on. With a clean DOJ Sessions will have a field day.
Brooke,
The truth is on your side!
Natural Born American can only mean one thing: a human being who is a full blooded American because they were born to American Parents under the USA Flag. Natural Born American Citizens have only one Country, only one Nationality. Anything else is something else. Different.
100% American, naturally.
QUESTION…………..off topic!
…………..If Trump was able to save 1000 jobs in Indiana, why the hell couldn’t Soetoro have done the same thing…………ANSWER……..MORON IN CHIEF……….more important to pursue his BACK DOOR BINGO WITH MICHAEL.
With a Little Divine Intervention !
I know that many do not believe that “the big guy” keeps an eye out for us – even when we ask him to do so, today was one of those days that again confirmed, at least for me, that He most certainly does – truly the “invisible hand” rested firmly on my shoulder as I discussed the A/G’s procedural objections and the underlying merits of the case with the Vermont Supreme Court Justices
The justices were well read on the case and asked pointed question. primarily on the procedural issues of standing, venue, jurisdiction and timeliness (mootness/ripeness), One justice stated to AA/G Daloz that “I believe that we will get past the procedural questions” to the issues of the case and then asked several probing question that Daloz seemed ill-prepared to address. Rubio’s “K Street” attorney, Brady Toesing was in attendance but had informed the court that he would not participate in Oral Argument – a decision he may now regret (I suspect that Rubio cut the cash flow to Brady?).
Daloz suggested that if the court found in my favor, that the case should be returned to the lower court for further briefing – however the justices did not seem amused, enquiring how additional briefing could help to clarify the issues. Between the lower court and the Supreme Court docket, the combined parties, State Defendants, Cruz and Rubio and I have submitted over a three thousand pages of material (taking up two file drawers in the clerk’s office!) I believe that the Attorney General’s office fears that if the court proceeds to the merits the issue of the Sec. of State’s responsibility to prohibit unqualified candidates from ballot access, the court’s jurisdiction to decide and the underlying question of confirming the SCOTUS definition of the birth circumstances* will not go well for the opposition !
It was a Good Day for Justice in the Green Mountains !
H. Brooke Paige
* – Inglis v. Sailors’ Snug Harbor, 28 U.S. 99 (1830), Dred Scott v. Sandford, 60 U.S. 393 (1857), Minor v. Happersett, 88 U.S. 162, 167 (1875), U.S. v. Wong Kim Ark, 169 U.S. 649, 665 (1898)
Thanks Mr. Paige.
Sue… what do you think? I guess you are still blogging here.
https://americafirstpatriots.com/controversy-alert-wherever-stand-vaccinations-worth-reading/
Trump’s & Rand Paul’s responses on vaccines were great.
I have been doing more research & have some common sense & research based answers.
Hope to report soon.
“More Bad News For Jill Stein As Pennsylvania Judge Blocks Recount Petitions”
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-12-01/more-bad-news-jill-stein-pennsylvania-judge-blocks-recount-petitions
So what’s up with this? Is this the ole buddy buddy system?
It was reported that Angela Merkel was involved in the US election. Direct connection has been made between her and Hillary Clinton.
Angela Merkel has been caught funnelling over $5 million of German taxpayers money to the Clinton Foundation in an underhanded effort to try and influence the recent U.S. elections.
Between July and September 2016, Merkel gave millions of German taxpayers money to the Clinton Foundation, according to German newspaper Die Welt.
According to a newly surfaced donor list, the Clinton charity received around $5 million from Germany’s Ministry for Environment. Ministry’s spokesperson said that they had “very positive experience” with the Clinton Foundation and the millions of dollars diverted to the Clintons were going to planting trees in countries like India, Mexico, and Vietnam.
The total amount of German taxpayer contribution to Clinton Foundation is not yet known. It is unclear if the Merkel government made further payments to the Clinton charity through other ministries or state-run agencies. German newspaper Die Welt details the government transaction:
The newly released list of donors show that Federal [German] Ministry for Environment transferred millions to the [Clinton] Foundation. In the third quarter of 2016, at the height of [Clinton’s] campaign, German taxpayers gave up to five million dollars to the family foundation.
Some observers believe that German government has some explaining to do for the donation that appears under the heading “Donors and Grantors”. “Why does a Ministry supports the election campaign of a U.S. presidential candidate?” asked Vera Lengsfeld — former civil rights activist and German parliamentarian — in her blog. “It seems German taxpayers unwittingly financed Hillary Clinton’s election campaign.”
Das ist schlecht!
CW………you are exactly right when you say this is bad……….Es gibt viel mehr.
CW……….
……….it goes without saying that the involvement of Mzzzzzzzzzz Merkel is far more involved than most realise. She is only a puppet.
…………the NAZI movement is NOT DEAD……….only DORMANT to the eye, and ear.
CW……..OFF TOPIC
…………and now FBI is saying it is TOO EARLY to call the OSU attacks TERRORISM. Now we know the FBI is in reality an extension of the Democratic party. Very sad.
……..
Monitoring FBI/Govt never off topic.
………if the attack on 11 people by a stinking a$$ED GOAT HERDER was NOT TERRORISM, I am very troubled by the dictionary that the FBI uses.
………..whether or not the attack was inspired by his own mind, or by ISIS is immaterial, he attempted to murder 11 people…..pure and simple……..One of the victims died. Now it is time for him to pay the fiddler……..a very high price! Something like life in prison.
hapnHal | December 1, 2016 at 9:27 am
************
Democrats just proved the old saying, money can’t buy everything.
Merkel’s money and the NWO, desperate to win, and perpetuate the EU.
Democrats outspent Trump by a huge margin, and his message of truth prevailed, and liars, and crooks lose.
Trump is about to speak in Indiana, on FOX news
Bob Strauss……….
……….Mzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. Merkel stated ” THERE WILL BE NO RETURN TO THE WORLD BEFORE GLOBALISATION.” What does that tell you? The Hitler envisioned NEW WORLD ORDER is still very much alive.
………..NEXT we will be hearing “YA VEE IST DER SUPERMEN”.
What Up in North Carolina?
http://www.newsobserver.com/news/local/community/durham-news/article76429192.html
Pete, this was mentioned during the NCSBOE emergency meeting Sunday before last.
The investigation is ongoing.
Of bigger concern is the Bladen County investigation underway that connects the NC Dem party to the general election & fraud.
Of course more chicanery may be revealed as the Durham County votes are recounted & hopefully scrutinized,
CW………
………AND NOW…….
…………….Trump has chosen Retired Marine Four Star General James Mattis for Secretary of Defense position. Trump couldn’t have chosen a better man. Three cheers for Trump, the same for General Mattis. hip hip hooray three times!
CW……….
…………..looking for big moderation trend in precious metals. Very slow downward price trends for precious metals……..measured in pennies for silver, and dollars for gold. Anomaly occurring! Time for STOP LOSS installation.
Bob strauss
One better yet. ..
It proves
That money does grow on trees !
Information available about the lack of constitutional eligibility of Cruz and Rubio is still online at this site: http://www.protectourliberty.org
Ginger | December 1, 2016 at 7:12 am |
Hi Ginger and yes, I’m still here.
I agree with President Trump. Vaccines have saved many lives, but IMO, they shouldn’t be given all at once.
I’m not sure if some of these vaccines contain ‘live’ constituents (as does the FluMist for seasonal flu) but if they do, administering them in one shot would certainly overwhelm a tiny system.
It’s up to parents to do their research and ask questions before *anything* is injected into their child.
Sue K….. Thank You
For those interesting in listening to the Audio Transcript of the Oral Arguments in Paige v. Vermont (II) they are now available on-line at https://www.vermontjudiciary.org/LC/Oral%20Arguments/2016-202.zip
:
Pingback: Kamala Harris eligible? Jonathan Turley says yes quotes flawed CRS report, Natural Born Citizen requirement, Citizen not enough, SCOTUS ruling required | Citizen WElls